Smoke from Indonesia’s wildfires appears to have pushed air pollution in Singapore to its highest level of the year on Wednesday, October 14, while East Timor ordered schools nationwide to stop in-person classes and Malaysia kept schools shut in several states, according to government data, official announcements and regional outlets. Reuters reported that Singapore’s one-hour PM2.5 reading “hit a high of 284 micrograms per cubic meter” in the west of the island and entered the agency’s “very high” band for the first time during the current haze period. The earliest report this desk read came from TATOLI, East Timor’s state news agency, which posted the school suspension at 10:30 AM Dili time on October 14 (6:30 PM PT on Tuesday, October 13); the Reuters story ran in the New Straits Times at 3:48 PM Singapore time (12:48 AM PT) and on NBC News, whose copy this desk read, at 5:13 AM EDT (2:13 AM PT).
The government’s own hourly figures, published through data.gov.sg, show how the day built. The west of Singapore read 111 micrograms per cubic metre at noon, 195 at 1 PM, 284 at 2 PM and 288 at 3 PM local time (midnight PT), then 251 at 4 PM and 274 at 8 PM before falling to 124 by 11 PM. Reuters’ figure of 284 matches the 2 PM reading; The Straits Times reports 288 at 3 PM and 251 at 4 PM, matching the data. The Straits Times says an hourly reading above 250 indicates a very high concentration of fine particles, and that NEA then advises the public to minimise outdoor activities for the next hour and vulnerable groups to avoid them altogether. The same data put the west’s 24-hour Pollutant Standards Index (PSI) at 205 by 11 PM; The Straits Times says the 24-hour PSI forecast remains in the unhealthy range. Reuters says Indonesian wildfires drove PM2.5 in the west of Singapore to a national record of 471 in October 2015.
Singapore kept its schools open. The Straits Times reports that Maris Stella High School canceled outdoor sports, Nan Hua High School canceled at least one co-curricular activity and Pasir Ris Secondary School canceled its football activity, and that CHIJ (Kellock) told parents it would suspend all outdoor activities, including physical education lessons, on October 15 and 16. According to The Straits Times, a Ministry of Education notice on October 10 said lessons would continue in enclosed, well-ventilated spaces with air purifiers should the 24-hour PSI exceed 200, and Education Minister Desmond Lee said the ministry may consider school closures and postponing national examinations if next-day forecasts enter the hazardous range above 300. “We will continue to monitor the situation closely each day and review whether schools should stay open or be closed the next day,” Lee said on October 10, the paper reports.
In Malaysia, Education Minister Fadhlina Sidek said in a Facebook post on October 13 that all schools in Johor, Melaka and Negeri Sembilan would close on October 14, along with schools under several district offices in Selangor, Pahang, Sabah and Sarawak, The Straits Times reports, with home-based teaching during the closure. The Sarawak education department based its decision on 2 PM air pollutant index (API) readings, and the state Natural Resources and Environment Board website showed 155 in Serian, 164 in Sri Aman and 179 in Lubok Antu, according to The Straits Times. For Thursday, The Star reports that the Johor State Education Department said all of the state’s schools would stay closed, that the Pahang department ordered schools in seven districts to halt outdoor activities, and that schools in Putrajaya, Kuala Lumpur, Selangor, Negeri Sembilan, Penang, Melaka, Perak and Sarawak would operate as usual with outdoor activities suspended. The Star says the state education departments told parents worried about the haze that they may keep children home if they inform the school. Reuters says several Malaysian states had to shut schools.
East Timor went further. TATOLI reports that the Ministry of Education and the Ministry of State Administration suspended in-person classes across the national territory from October 15 to 17, in a document signed by Domingos Lopes Lemos, secretary of state for secondary education, and António Augusto Guterres, a director-general at the state administration ministry, covering public, private and cooperative schools in the public network from pre-school through secondary level. TATOLI’s lead attributes the poor air to smoke from fires in Indonesia, while the statement, as TATOLI paraphrases it, refers to smoke from fires in the neighboring country; Reuters says the government statement cited “contamination by pollutant particles from wildfires in neighboring regions or countries” and did not identify Indonesia by name, noting that East Timor shares an island with part of Indonesia’s East Nusa Tenggara province, where Reuters notes a number of reported hotspots. The Oekusi Post says in-person classes should resume on Monday, October 19, subject to confirmation, and that the national meteorology directorate (DNMG) expects winds to carry smoke back to Timor on October 16 and 17, a period that coincides with field burning by farmers in East Timor. TATOLI, citing a DNMG bulletin, says smoke from Indonesia’s West Papua region may affect the municipalities of Lautém, Baucau and Viqueque from Friday.
President José Ramos-Horta, TATOLI reports, expressed solidarity with Indonesia on Facebook, praising the emergency crews and firefighters working to put out the fires, and urged people in East Timor to limit outdoor activity and wear masks such as N95s if they must go out (TATOLI’s Indonesian-language report; this desk’s translation). TATOLI’s Portuguese report says the schools document also cites his concern over the effect of smoke on the health of children and young people in schools.
Inside Indonesia, the Forestry Ministry’s SiPongi monitoring system counted 20,334 hotspots in the 24 hours to Wednesday, 9,297 more than in the previous period, according to TATOLI and the Indonesian data site Databoks; both list Central Kalimantan first with 11,166, followed by South Sumatra (2,404) and South Kalimantan (1,156). Databoks says 1,784 of the hotspots carried high confidence, 17,916 medium and 634 low, from Terra/Aqua, SNPP and NOAA satellite data accessed at 11:15 AM western Indonesia time. TATOLI notes that a hotspot marks a surface temperature higher than its surroundings and does not always mean an active fire. Reuters says Indonesia faces its most intense wildfire season in 11 years, fueled by El Niño-related dry weather, and that President Prabowo Subianto ordered additional resources deployed. “We are mobilizing all our resources and capabilities,” Honi Havana, an official at the Coordinating Ministry for Political and Security Affairs, said at a Wednesday news briefing, according to Reuters, which says he put the firefighting force at more than 69,000, up from around 44,000 in mid-September. Disaster mitigation agency spokesperson Berton Panjaitan said authorities struggle with peatland fires that smoulder beneath the surface and can re-emerge, Reuters reports, quoting him: “We must recognize that the only way to resolve this is through sustained rainfall.”
Reuters also reports mounting criticism of Indonesia across the region as Southeast Asian foreign ministers prepare to discuss transboundary haze at an ASEAN meeting next month. On Tuesday, Malaysian lawmaker Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman told parliament, “We must send a very clear diplomatic protest,” and, as Reuters quotes him, “You need to treat them like an outcast in the region,” adding that Malaysian and Singaporean banks should cut off financing to companies linked to land burning. This desk found no Indonesian government reply to that call in the sources it read. Seems News reading note: Singapore’s readings come straight from NEA data and match The Straits Times; the school decisions come from ministries via TATOLI, The Oekusi Post, The Straits Times and The Star; the fire counts come from Indonesia’s own satellite system and carry its caveat. Watch for Singapore’s next-day PSI forecasts and any school-closure call, Malaysia’s state-by-state notices, whether East Timor reopens classrooms on October 19, and the ASEAN haze talks.
